PianoToMIDI

Accuracy

How accurate is PianoToMIDI?

What has been measured, how, and what makes a result better or worse. Updated November 2026.

The short answer

On a clean recording of piano alone, most notes come out right, with their timing and how hard they were played, and the sustain pedal. About 92–98% of notes land in the right hand, depending on the test. Voices, other instruments or a backing track come through as extra notes, so treat a busy recording’s result as a draft to correct.

Left and right hand separation

The notes are split between the hands automatically. The results below were measured with the two rule sets it has used: one for jazz, stride and ragtime, where the left hand leaps, and one for classical.

TestStyleResult
231 two-staff classical scores from the ASAP dataset, with the staff standing in for the hand and the timing roughened to sound playedClassicalAbout 92% of notes in the right hand
The same scores, with the earlier version—About 65%
Three recordings of the founder playing, each note’s hand read from overhead videoClassicalAbout 98%
The same three recordingsJazzAbout 94%
46 notes a user corrected by hand in three stride recordingsJazzAll 46 now come out in the right hand

For comparison, published research systems trained for hand assignment report about 93–94%. The classical style was checked on scores it wasn’t tuned on. The jazz style is made for stride, so it isn’t expected to match on classical scores.

Limits: the ASAP figure is from scores with the timing roughened, not real recordings, and the video-checked and stride figures come from three recordings each. Treat them as estimates of what you’ll get.

What lowers accuracy

Check it on your own recording

Numbers from test sets only go so far. The free plan transcribes up to 10 recordings every 30 days, each one to play in full (up to 15 minutes) and its first 30 seconds to download as MIDI, with the hands separated and the MIDI to download, so you can hear the result on your own music before paying. Try a recording.

Questions

How accurate is PianoToMIDI?

On a clean recording of piano alone, most notes come out right, with their timing and how hard they were played. Voices, other instruments or a backing track add extra notes, so a busy recording’s result is a draft to correct. The hand separation is measured: about 92% of notes in the right hand on 231 classical scores, and 94–98% on recordings with each note’s hand checked against video.

How accurate is the left and right hand separation?

About 92% of notes on 231 classical scores from the ASAP dataset, and about 98% (classical style) and 94% (jazz style) on three real recordings checked against overhead video. Published research systems trained for the job report about 93–94%.

How can I check it on my own recording before paying?

The free plan transcribes up to 10 recordings every 30 days, each one to play in full (up to 15 minutes) and its first 30 seconds to download as MIDI, with the hands separated and the MIDI to download. No card needed.